Write for us
Write, shoot or film for The Aston Goose. Pitch through the Submit page. Tell us the story, why it matters and who you would talk to.
We welcome reporting, explainers, analysis, culture, photography and film from Aston and Birmingham. Link to sources and tell us what you can verify.
Pitch a story ↗ or email Editor@theastongoose.com.
The Aston Goose: Contributor's Guide in Two Pages
Nov 15, 2026 · @Jaffer Ali
The short version of the full Contributor's Handbook. Read this first, then use the handbook when you need detail.
The one rule
If you state a fact, prove it. If you make an argument, show your reasoning. If the evidence proves you wrong, change your mind. Everything else follows from that.
Our five standards
• Accurate: every fact can be checked.
• Independent: the uni, the SU, parties and advertisers don't tell us what to write.
• Fair: people and arguments are shown as they really are.
• Clear: readers get it first time.
• Accountable: you own your work and fix your mistakes.
From idea to article
• Find a story, not a topic. "Student housing" is a topic. "How much have Birmingham student rents risen in five years?" is a story.
• Pick your angle. Finish this sentence: "This article looks at [subject] to find out [question]." If you can't, keep thinking.
• Pitch it. Tell an editor what the story is, why now, who it affects, what evidence you have and what you still need.
• Research it. Answer who, what, when, where, why and how. Then ask what nobody's saying.
• Write it. Most important thing first. One idea per paragraph.
• Edit it three times: facts, then structure, then language. Then read it out loud.
• Send it in with sources, photo credits and a short bio if you're new.
Checking your facts
• Go to the original. Find the ONS release, the actual study, the council document. Not a news article about it.
• Check important claims more than once. Three sites copying one press release is still one source.
• Label every claim: verified (proven, state it as fact), attributed (someone said it, so write "the council said") or unverified (leave it out).
• Give numbers context. Over what period? From what to what? Adjusted for inflation? Where's the data from?
• Happening together isn't causing. Rule out other explanations before you claim one thing caused another.
• Your conclusion can never be stronger than your evidence.
Interviews
• Say you're from The Aston Goose, agree if it's on the record and ask before recording.
• Ask open questions. Then follow up: "How do you know that?" "Can you give an example?"
• Quotes are their exact words. Never invent or combine them.
Writing it
| Part | Do this |
|---|---|
| Headline | Say what happened. No clickbait. About 50 to 75 characters. |
| Standfirst | One or two lines that add something the headline didn't. |
| Opening | Who or what + what happened + when or where + why it matters. |
| Middle | One idea per paragraph, two to four sentences, each backed up. |
| Ending | What happens next or what's still unknown. Never "only time will tell". |
Sound like a human
Our readers hate AI writing and can spot it. Use British spelling, plain words and real details. Cut these:
• Em dashes (—)
• "In today's fast-paced world" and similar openers
• Delve, landscape, crucial, pivotal, moreover, furthermore
• "It's not just X, it's Y"
• Everything in threes, every paragraph the same length
Lines you don't cross
• An accusation is an allegation until proven. Give the person or organisation a chance to reply.
• Declare any personal link to the story. No freebies or payments for good coverage.
• No copying. Credit every source, photo and quote. A Google image is not free to use.
• Take extra care with vulnerable people, under-18s, health and trauma.
• AI can help you plan or check grammar. It can't check facts. Never hand in made-up quotes, numbers or sources. Tell the editors if AI did a lot of the work.
• Got something wrong? Tell the editors. We correct it openly.
How long?
| Type | Words |
|---|---|
| News brief | 150 to 250 |
| News report | 300 to 500 |
| Review / Explainer | 400 to 800 |
| Feature / Interview | 500 to 900 |
| Analysis / Opinion | 600 to 1,000 |
A sharp 250 words beats a padded 800.
Before you hit send
• ☐ My angle is clear and my first paragraph says what happened.
• ☐ Every important fact is checked and every source credited.
• ☐ Every quote is word for word.
• ☐ British spelling, no em dashes, no filler.
• ☐ Section, headline, standfirst, byline, sources and photo credits are all there.
• ☐ I've declared any conflict of interest and any big AI help.
We'd rather publish a well-researched piece that disagrees with us than a lazy one that agrees. Take your words, your evidence and your readers seriously.
The Aston Goose: Contributor's Handbook
Nov 15, 2026 · @Jaffer Ali
Before you start
The truth is, most student newspapers die the year their founders graduate. The Aston Goose nearly did.
I started The Aston Goose in March 2020 as a project of the Aston newspaper society. When I graduated in 2021, the team went its separate ways. I could have let it go. Instead I kept it alive as an Instagram page, sharing student stories, events and the work of other societies.
Over those years it worked with university departments, the Students' Union and local charities. It stayed small, but it never stopped. Now a new team is bringing it back as a proper newspaper. If you are reading this, you are part of that team.
I believe students deserve a paper of their own. Not a noticeboard for the university, and not a place to shout without evidence. A place to ask awkward questions, explain what is happening in Aston and Birmingham, and argue for what you think.
You don't need a journalism degree to write for us. You don't need big words or years of practice. You need curiosity, a willingness to learn and something worth saying.
Writing is thinking. When you sit down to write, you find out what you actually believe and whether you can prove it. Knowing something, believing it and being able to show it is true are three different things. Unfortunately, a lot of what gets published online never learns the difference.
You don't have to agree with me, with the editors or with each other. I would be worried if you did. What I ask is simple. If you state a fact, prove it. If you make an argument, show your reasoning. If the evidence says you are wrong, change your mind.
This handbook shows you how. Read it properly once, then keep it open every time you write.
Jaffer Ali
Founding Editor, The Aston Goose
1. What The Aston Goose is
The Aston Goose is an independent digital paper started by students. We cover four patches:
| Section | What goes in it |
|---|---|
| Aston | Campus life, the SU, societies, research, student problems |
| Birmingham | The council, transport, local businesses, communities |
| UK | National politics, the economy, education, society |
| The World | International news and big global stories |
Every section also has Sport, Culture and Finance. On top of news, we run interviews, features, reviews, explainers and opinion pieces.
These sections are just how we sort things. They don't limit what you write. Student rents, a local founder, a new science discovery, an exhibition in Digbeth: all welcome, as long as there's a real story in it.
Our five rules
Everything we publish, news or opinion or review, has to pass these:
• Accurate. Every fact can be checked.
• Independent. Nobody tells us what to write. Not the university, not the SU, not a political party, not an advertiser.
• Fair. People and arguments are shown as they really are.
• Clear. A reader gets it first time.
• Accountable. You own your work. If you get something wrong, you fix it.
What you owe the reader
Someone reading your piece is giving you their time and trusting you. Don't waste either.
• Don't make something sound bigger than it is.
• Don't leave out evidence just because it spoils your point.
• Don't pass off a guess as a fact.
• Don't confuse sounding confident with being right.
The test is simple. After reading your article, does the reader know more than they did before?
2. Finding a story
A topic is not a story. "Student housing" is a topic. "How much have Birmingham student rents gone up in five years?" is a story. The question is what tells you where to look.
Where ideas come from
Start with what's around you. SU decisions, uni emails, council meetings, new research, match results, the café that just shut down. Listen to what people complain about in the library queue.
Then ask the obvious questions nobody bothers with. Why did this change? Who decided? How much did it cost? Who wins? Does it actually work? Small things often turn out to affect a lot of people.
Is it worth writing?
Run it past these six questions. You don't need a yes to all of them.
| Question | Ask yourself |
|---|---|
| Is it new? | Did it just happen, or is something about to happen? |
| Who does it hit? | How many people, and how badly? |
| Will our readers care? | Would a student or someone living in Birmingham stop scrolling for it? |
| Is it close to home? | Aston, Birmingham, or a community we cover? |
| Does it matter? | Does it explain something bigger? |
| Can we add something? | Do we know or show something nobody else has? |
Who's reading matters. A change to library hours can be a bigger story for Aston students than a billion-pound merger.
Pick your angle
Your angle is the specific question your piece answers. Narrow it down until you can research it.
• Topic: buses
• Rough idea: buses in Birmingham are expensive
• Angle: how much do bus fares eat into the monthly budget of a student commuting to Aston?
Now you know what to look for: fares, discounts, how often people travel, what else they could use.
Before you start, finish this sentence:
"This article looks at [subject] to find out [question]."
If you can't, your angle isn't ready. And remember, an angle is a question, not an answer. If the research proves your hunch wrong, write what you found.
Pitching to the editors
A pitch is a short message telling us what you want to write. Answer six things:
• What's the story?
• Why now?
• Who's affected?
• What evidence do you already have?
• What do you still need to find out?
• Why should The Aston Goose run it?
Example pitch (made up, for practice only)
Working headline: Are Birmingham student rents rising faster than student loans?
Section: Aston | Finance
Angle: Compare how rents have changed with how maintenance support has changed.
Research needed: Rent data, Student Finance figures, interviews with students, comments from landlords.
Why readers care: Rent is most students' biggest bill.
Format and length: Data explainer, about 600 words.
Try it: pick something you care about and write a 100 to 150 word pitch. If it doesn't say what the article will find out, keep working on the angle.
3. Research and checking your facts
Imagine publishing a figure that turns out to be wrong. Every reader who saw it now has a reason to doubt everything else you wrote, and everything else we publish. I believe this is the most important chapter in the handbook. Skip it and nothing else will save your article.
The six basic questions
Every news story has to answer Who, What, When, Where, Why and How. Say the uni announces longer library hours. You'd find out:
• Who: the university, library staff, the students using it
• What: exactly which hours are changing
• When: when it was announced, when it starts
• Where: which buildings
• Why: the reason they gave, and whether there's evidence for it
• How: the new timetable and how access works
Then ask what they didn't say. Are there extra staff? Is everything open in those hours? Did anyone actually ask students if they wanted this? That's usually where the real story is.
Plan before you dig
Before you start, jot down a quick plan so you don't end up with 40 open tabs and no idea why:
• The question I'm trying to answer
• What I already know and have checked
• What I still need
• Where I'll get it: documents, data, people
• What could prove me wrong
• Deadline
Primary and secondary sources
Primary sources come straight from the source: official documents, government statistics, research papers, court rulings, company accounts, your own interviews, photos and things you saw yourself.
Secondary sources report on someone else's information: newspapers, magazines, blogs, commentary.
Both are useful, but always try to get back to the original. If a paper says unemployment went up, find the ONS release. If the uni claims a research breakthrough, read the actual study and its limits. If a company says its product saves energy, find out who measured that and how.
Good places to start
• Aston and Birmingham: aston.ac.uk, astonsu.com, birmingham.gov.uk, wmca.org.uk
• UK: gov.uk, ons.gov.uk, parliament.uk, legislation.gov.uk
• World: reuters.com, apnews.com, un.org, worldbank.org, imf.org
• Research: Google Scholar, university repositories, peer-reviewed journals
These are starting points. Official sources get things wrong too, so check them like anything else.
Check it more than once
Don't trust one source on anything important. If the uni says a new scheme improved student satisfaction, look at three things: the announcement, the survey behind it (how many people, what questions), and what students or outside evidence say.
Watch out: three news sites copying the same press release is still one source. Always trace a claim back to where it started.
Keep an evidence log
For bigger stories, keep a simple table of every important claim before you write.
| Claim | Where it came from | What I checked | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rent went up by X% | Rent dataset | The maths and how the data was collected | Not yet |
| Policy starts on a set date | Official document | The actual start date | Checked |
| Students are against it | Interviews | How many people, who said what | Not yet |
Mark each claim one of three ways:
• Verified: solid, reliable evidence backs it up. You can state it as fact.
• Attributed: someone said it, but you haven't proved it. Write "the council said", not "it is true that".
• Unverified: not enough evidence. It doesn't go in as a fact. Full stop.
Numbers can lie
A statistic without context is how people get misled. Take "Student rents have gone up 20%". Before you print that, ask:
• Over how long?
• From what to what?
• Which kind of housing?
• Is it an average, a median, or one flat?
• Has it been adjusted for inflation?
• Where's the data from?
How to work out a percentage change: (new number minus old number) divided by old number, times 100.
So if weekly rent goes from £150 to £180: (180 − 150) ÷ 150 × 100 = 20%.
The maths is easy. Explaining it is the hard bit. A 20% rise in price isn't a 20% rise once you take inflation into account. And it doesn't tell you why rent went up.
Two things happening together doesn't mean one caused the other
More students at Aston and higher rents might be linked. They might not. It could be fewer new flats, higher building costs, or the whole Birmingham rental market going up. Rule out the other explanations before you claim a cause.
The golden rule: your conclusion can never be stronger than your evidence.
4. Interviews and quotes
Talking to real people is what makes a piece feel alive, and it's the one thing AI can't fake for you. A good quote from someone who was there beats three paragraphs of your own description.
Before the interview
• Read up on the person and the subject.
• Write questions that can't be answered with yes or no.
• Know what information you actually need from them.
• Tell them you're writing for The Aston Goose.
• Agree whether it's on the record (you can name and quote them) or not.
• Ask before you record. Every time.
Ask good questions
Bad: "Don't you think the uni should do more?"
That tells them the answer you want.
Better: "What problems have students raised, and what has the uni done about them?"
The best stuff usually comes from the follow-up, not the first question. Keep these in your back pocket:
• "How do you know that?"
• "Can you give me an example?"
• "When was this?"
• "Where does that number come from?"
• "What would you say to someone who disagrees?"
And actually listen. If you're staring at your list waiting to ask question four, you'll miss the best answer of the day.
Quoting people
• A quote in quotation marks has to be their exact words.
• Never make up a quote, or glue two separate things they said into one.
• If you paraphrase, keep their meaning.
• Say who they are and why they matter: for example, "Sara Khan, a second-year law student living in halls".
• Never suggest you interviewed someone if you didn't.
Interviewing someone vulnerable, or dealing with a serious accusation? Talk to the editors first.
Try it: find a recent announcement from the uni, the council or the government. Pick three claims in it. Trace each one back to evidence. Write down whether the evidence actually proves it, or whether it's just the organisation saying so.
5. Writing the article
Sketch the order first
For a news story, put the most important thing at the top and work down. Journalists call this the inverted pyramid: if a reader stops after one paragraph, they still got the main point.
• What happened
• The key facts
• Numbers, quotes, evidence
• Background
• What it means and what's still unknown
• What happens next, if we know
Other pieces can be built differently. A feature can tell a story in time order. A review can go through the film one part at a time. Use whatever shape makes it easiest to follow.
The headline
Say what the story is. No clickbait, no exaggeration, no hiding the point.
| Weak | Better |
|---|---|
| Students Face Shocking Housing Crisis! | Birmingham Student Rents Rise as Housing Costs Climb |
| Aston University Makes Major Announcement | Aston University Announces New Engineering Scholarships |
A good headline names the subject, uses specific words, uses an active verb, matches the evidence and makes sense on its own. Aim for about 50 to 75 characters, but getting it right matters more than the count.
The standfirst
The standfirst is the line or two under the headline. It adds something new and gives people a reason to keep reading. Don't just repeat the headline, and don't sneak in claims you can't back up.
Headline: Birmingham Student Rents Rise as Housing Costs Climb
Standfirst: New rent figures point to growing pressure on student budgets, and questions about whether support is keeping up.
The opening paragraph
The first paragraph (the lead) is the most important one you'll write. In a news story it should tell the reader what happened, straight away.
Weak: "Accommodation has always been an important part of university life, and in recent years there have been many discussions about the challenges students face."
That says nothing.
Better: "Average student rents in Birmingham rose by 20% over five years, according to [source], leaving students with less money for everything else."
That gives a fact, a place, a time and why it matters.
A simple formula: who or what + what happened + when or where + why it matters.
You don't need to cram all six questions into one sentence. Never open a news story with a dramatic question, a big philosophical statement or "In today's world".
The middle
One idea per paragraph. Make the point, then back it up.
Weak: "Student rents are rising and people are worried, while universities are expanding and Birmingham has lots of new buildings, which means the housing market is changing."
Four ideas crushed together with no link between them.
Better: split them up. One paragraph on how rising rent squeezes student budgets. Another on what might be pushing rents up. Each one with its own evidence.
Most people read on their phones, so keep paragraphs to two to four sentences. Go longer if the argument needs it. But don't make every sentence its own paragraph either. That's just as hard to read.
Quotes and saying where things came from
A quote should add something: a fact, an experience, a reaction to criticism. "The event was really successful," said an organiser, adds nothing.
Always make clear where important information came from:
• "According to the Office for National Statistics…"
• "The university said in a statement…"
• "Researchers found in their study…"
This shows the reader what you found and what someone else claims. Link to the original wherever you can.
Make an argument that holds together
Use this order: claim, evidence, context, analysis, conclusion.
Say you're asking whether student housing has become less affordable:
• Claim: housing may be squeezing student budgets harder.
• Evidence: checked rent figures and Student Finance figures.
• Context: inflation, different types of housing, different students' situations.
• Analysis: compare what housing costs with what support covers.
• Conclusion: what the evidence actually shows, no more.
Don't decide your conclusion first and then go hunting for evidence that fits.
The ending
You don't need a paragraph that repeats everything. For news, end on something useful: what happens next, an open question, a deadline, or a reply you're still waiting on.
Weak: "Only time will tell what happens next, but one thing is certain: this issue will remain important."
Better: "The council will vote on the plan in December. No start date has been set." (made-up example)
Opinion and analysis can end on your final verdict, as long as it follows from what you've shown.
6. Types of article
Each type has a different job. Know which one you're writing before you start, because it changes how you write it.
| Type | Its job | Example | Length (words) |
|---|---|---|---|
| News brief | Say quickly what happened | SU announces new election date | 150 to 250 |
| News report | Say what happened, who's involved, why it matters | Council approves new bus lane on the A38 | 300 to 500 |
| Feature | Go deeper into a person, place or issue | How international students settle into Birmingham | 500 to 900 |
| Interview | Let someone tell it first-hand | A student founder on running a business alongside a degree | 500 to 900 |
| Analysis | Explain causes, effects and what it all means | What graduate job figures say about the UK job market | 600 to 1,000 |
| Opinion | Argue a position with evidence | Why the uni should rethink its hardship fund | 600 to 1,000 |
| Review | Give a fair, specific verdict | A new restaurant in the Jewellery Quarter | 400 to 700 |
| Explainer | Break down something complicated | What a fall in inflation actually means for prices | 400 to 800 |
Lengths are a guide, not a rule. A sharp 250 words beats a padded 800. Write what the story needs and stop.
A few things to keep in mind for each:
• News is about facts, not your feelings.
• Features can be told like a story, but every fact still gets checked.
• Analysis has to make clear which bits are proven and which bits are your reading of them.
• Opinion is not a free pass on facts. Take on the strongest argument against you, fairly.
• Interviews are someone's account. Check the facts they give you (money raised, awards, partnerships) separately.
• Reviews are personal, but say exactly what worked, what didn't, and why. "It was amazing" is not a review.
• Explainers should cover what the reader needs to know, explain any jargon, and give context.
7. House style: write like a person
Good writing isn't about long words. It's about the reader getting your point without having to work for it. Write it the way you would explain it out loud, then tidy it up.
The basics
• British English. Realise, colour, organise, programme, favour, defence.
• Be specific. Numbers, names, places, dates.
• Cut what doesn't earn its place. If a sentence adds no fact, reason or detail, delete it.
• No em dashes (the long dash: —). Use a full stop or a comma.
Common problems and how to fix them
| Problem | Weak | Better |
|---|---|---|
| Vague | "The university has made significant improvements." | "The university has added three study spaces and opened the library two hours later on weekdays." |
| Claiming too much | "The new policy will undoubtedly improve student satisfaction." | "The university expects the policy to improve satisfaction, but it hasn't been tested yet." |
| Showing off | "In today's rapidly evolving educational landscape, students are increasingly confronted with a multitude of complex financial challenges." | "Students are under more money pressure as rent and living costs go up." |
(All examples are made up.)
Our readers can spot AI a mile off
If your piece sounds like a chatbot wrote it, people stop trusting it. Watch for these giveaways and cut them:
• Openers like "In today's fast-paced world" or "In an era of"
• Words like delve, landscape, tapestry, navigate, crucial, pivotal, robust, moreover, furthermore
• "It's not just X, it's Y"
• Everything in groups of three ("bold, brave and brilliant")
• Endings like "Ultimately, only time will tell" or "One thing is clear"
• Every paragraph the same length and rhythm
• Em dashes everywhere
The fix is almost always the same: say the actual thing, in plain words, with a real detail.
Check your own bias
Everyone has opinions. That's fine. Just make sure they don't replace the evidence. Before you submit, ask yourself:
• Did I pick evidence because it agrees with me?
• Have I thought about other explanations?
• Have I been fair to people who disagree?
• Have I mixed up "happened at the same time" with "caused"?
• Does my conclusion go further than my evidence?
Edit in three rounds
Your first draft will not be your best. Nobody's is. Go through it three times, looking for one thing each time.
• Facts. Names, dates, quotes, numbers, sources. Is every conclusion backed up?
• Structure. Is the main point clear and near the top? Cut any paragraph that isn't pulling its weight.
• Language. Cut repetition, filler words and anything vague. Check spelling (British), grammar and punctuation.
Then read it out loud. If you trip over a sentence, so will the reader.
8. Doing the right thing
I'll be direct about this chapter. Break any of these rules and the article doesn't run, however good the rest of it is. A newspaper lives on trust. Unfortunately, once readers stop trusting you, no correction brings all of them back.
Be accurate and fair
• Check every important fact before you send it in.
• An accusation is an allegation until it's proven. Write it that way.
• Give the other side a fair hearing. That doesn't mean pretending every claim is equally backed up.
• If you're making a serious claim about a named person or organisation, tell the editors and give them a chance to respond.
• If you can't prove it, don't print it as fact.
Stay independent
The Aston Goose is not run by Aston University, the SU, any political group or any company. We're not anyone's PR team. But we don't invent outrage for clicks either. Criticise whoever you like, as long as the evidence is there.
• If you have a personal link to the story (you're on the society's committee, your mate owns the café), tell the editors.
• Don't take money, free stuff or favours in return for good coverage unless the editors have agreed and it's clearly labelled. Sponsored content is always marked as sponsored.
Respect people
• Take extra care with anything involving vulnerable people, under-18s, accusations of misconduct, health or traumatic events.
• Just because something is online doesn't mean you should publish it. Ask: does the public really need to know, and is that worth the harm it could do?
• No discriminatory language. Don't describe someone's appearance or background unless it matters to the story.
• Go after ideas, decisions and institutions when they deserve it. Never go after people personally.
Don't copy
• Your work has to be yours.
• You can quote and discuss other articles, but you can't pass off someone else's reporting as your own.
• Credit every source, photo, graphic and quote.
• A picture on Google or Instagram is not free to use. If it's Creative Commons, check the exact licence and follow it.
Using AI
AI can help you plan, check grammar, organise notes or think of questions to ask. It cannot check facts for you, and it gets things wrong with total confidence.
• You are responsible for every fact in your piece. "ChatGPT said so" is not a source.
• Never hand in made-up quotes, interviews, references, numbers or observations.
• Tell the editors if AI did a big chunk of the work.
• Don't paste confidential sources, sensitive interviews or private information into AI tools without permission.
• And remember: our readers can tell. If it reads like AI, it'll be sent back.
When you get it wrong
Everyone makes mistakes. What matters is how you deal with them.
• Spot an error? Tell the editors straight away.
• Real factual mistakes get corrected openly, with a note saying what changed and when.
• Never quietly edit a published claim to cover up the original error.
9. Photos, phones and making it readable for everyone
Write for a phone screen
Most people will read your piece on their phone, on the bus, half-distracted. Help them:
• Clear headline and standfirst
• Short paragraphs
• Subheadings that say what's coming
• Links to your sources, built into the text
• Tables only when they genuinely make a comparison easier
SEO is nice, but never bend the truth to rank higher. Write for people, not Google.
Photos
• Take your own where you can. It's the easiest way to stay out of trouble.
• Using someone else's? Get permission or check the licence, and send us the photographer's name, where it came from and the credit they need.
• Don't edit a photo in a way that changes what happened.
• Captions say what the photo shows. If it's a stock or file photo, don't pass it off as the event you're writing about.
Accessibility
Your article should work for as many people as possible, including people using screen readers.
• Use headings that describe what's below them.
• Explain or avoid jargon.
• Write alt text for any image that carries information ("Students queue outside the Main Building for the open day", not "image1.jpg").
• Don't rely on colour alone to show something in a chart.
• Link with real words, not "click here".
• If you use a chart or table, say its main point in the text too.
10. Sending it in
What to send, in this order
• Section and category, e.g. Aston | Finance
• Headline
• Standfirst: one or two sentences
• Byline: the name you want printed
• The article, with paragraphs and subheadings
• Sources: links to everything you used
• Photos, with credits and permission details
• A short bio if it's your first piece
Keep the formatting simple. No all-caps articles, no decorative fonts, no made-up dates or wrong photo credits. Put links in the text where they belong, and also list them at the bottom so editors can check them quickly.
For word counts, see the table in section 6.
What happens next
An editor reads every piece. They will do one of five things:
• Accept it.
• Ask you to clarify something or send more evidence.
• Suggest changes to structure or style.
• Ask for more reporting or fact-checking.
• Turn it down if it isn't up to standard.
Editors can fix small grammar, spelling and formatting issues themselves. Anything that changes your meaning or argument will be talked through with you first. Sending it in doesn't guarantee it gets published. We judge on accuracy, originality, relevance and quality.
How we score it
Use this to mark your own piece before you send it.
| What we look at | Points |
|---|---|
| Facts are accurate and checked | 25 |
| Research and sources | 20 |
| Reasoning and context | 15 |
| Structure and readability | 15 |
| Original and relevant to readers | 10 |
| Language and house style | 10 |
| Ready to publish | 5 |
| Total | 100 |
• 90 to 100: strong, nearly ready to go.
• 80 to 89: good, needs a few changes.
• 70 to 79: promising, needs real work.
• Under 70: go back to the research or rewrite.
The score is a guide, not an automatic decision. Serious factual errors, plagiarism, unproven accusations or privacy breaches mean the piece doesn't run until they're fixed, whatever it scores.
11. Worked examples
Every number here is made up for practice. Never publish any of it as real news.
A news story, start to finish
1. Topic: student housing costs in Birmingham.
2. Angle: have rents gone up faster than the money students get to live on?
3. What we need: old and new rent prices, maintenance loan figures, inflation data, students to talk to, replies from landlords, info on how much new housing is being built.
4. The (made-up) data:
| Five years ago | Now | |
|---|---|---|
| Average weekly rent | £150 | £180 |
| Rent over a 40-week year | £6,000 | £7,200 |
| Example student support | £7,000 | £7,500 |
Rent is up 20%. Support is up about 7.1%. That points to a problem. But it doesn't prove every student is worse off. Support depends on your circumstances, rent depends on the type of place, and we haven't adjusted for inflation.
5. The draft:
ASTON | FINANCE
Student rents outpace support in Birmingham
Rents have risen almost three times faster than student support, raising questions about how far a loan stretches.
Average student rents in Birmingham rose 20% in five years, while student support rose about 7%, according to [source].
Weekly rent went from £150 to £180. Over a 40-week academic year, that takes the yearly bill from £6,000 to £7,200. Support rose from £7,000 to £7,500 over the same period.
In the past, rent took up about 86% of that support. Now it's 96%.
That doesn't mean every student is in the same position. Support depends on household income, and rents vary with location, room type and whether bills are included.
It's also not clear why rents rose. Fewer new flats, higher building costs and the wider Birmingham rental market could all play a part. More students arriving at the same time as rents climbed doesn't prove one caused the other.
The Aston Goose has asked [landlord or provider] for comment.
6. Why it works: it asks one clear question, compares two numbers properly, shows the maths, gives context, doesn't claim a cause it can't prove, admits what it doesn't know and says what's still being chased. It doesn't pretend half the evidence is the full answer.
An opinion piece
Weak: "Universities should do more because students are struggling and education is important." That's a feeling, not an argument.
Stronger:
• Position: the uni should check whether its hardship support actually covers what students spend.
• Evidence: what students spend, who qualifies for hardship funds, the uni's budget, relevant research.
• Strongest argument against: the uni has limited money and other things to pay for.
• Weighing it up: how big is the need, what's affordable, what happens under each option?
• Conclusion: a realistic recommendation that follows from all that.
The point isn't to say what you want. It's to build an argument that survives someone trying to knock it down.
A review
Weak: "The film was amazing. The acting was brilliant and everyone should watch it." Tells us you liked it. Nothing else.
Stronger: go through the parts. Does the story hang together? Are the characters believable? How are the scenes put together? Does the way it looks help tell the story? What does the music add? Then your verdict: what worked, what didn't, and why. Positive or negative is fine. Just be able to explain it.
An interview with a student founder
Prepare: research the business, its market and the person. Decide your main question, e.g. "What's hard about starting a business while you're still studying?"
Questions you could ask:
• What problem were you trying to solve?
• How did you spot the gap?
• What did you need to get started?
• What was the hardest thing early on?
• How did you pay for it?
• What did you get wrong?
• How do you know it's working?
• What would you do differently?
• What would you tell someone thinking of doing the same?
Afterwards: check what they told you about money raised, sales, awards or partners. Ask for proof where it matters. Their story is valuable, but it isn't evidence on its own.
An explainer on inflation
The question: when inflation "falls", what does that actually mean for prices?
The key point: inflation falling doesn't mean prices are falling. It means they're going up more slowly.
A simple example: a basket of shopping costs £100. A year later it's £110 (10% inflation). The year after, it's £115.50. Inflation has "fallen" to 5%, but the shopping is still more expensive than ever.
For a real explainer you'd use the latest ONS release, say which measure you're using (CPI, for example) and what's driving the change.
12. Final checklist
Tick every box before you hit send.
The story
• ☐ I know exactly what my angle is.
• ☐ The first paragraph says what happened.
• ☐ Who, what, when, where, why and how are covered where they matter.
• ☐ It's in a logical order.
• ☐ The headline matches what the article actually says.
• ☐ The standfirst adds something new.
The facts
• ☐ I've checked every important fact.
• ☐ Every number has context (over what period, compared to what).
• ☐ Every source is reliable and credited.
• ☐ Every quote is word for word.
• ☐ Allegations are written as allegations.
• ☐ I've considered other explanations.
• ☐ Anyone I've made a serious claim about has had a chance to reply.
The writing
• ☐ It's clear and direct.
• ☐ British spelling throughout.
• ☐ No repetition, no filler, no em dashes.
• ☐ Any jargon is explained.
• ☐ My conclusion follows from my evidence.
• ☐ I've read it out loud.
The extras
• ☐ Section and category are at the top.
• ☐ Source links are included.
• ☐ Photos have permission and credits.
• ☐ I've declared any personal link to the story.
• ☐ I've told the editors if AI helped a lot.
• ☐ My name and contact details are included.
One last thing
Nobody writes like a professional the first time. I don't expect perfection. I expect you to take the work seriously.
You get better by writing, researching, being edited and trying again. Some of your drafts will be a mess. Some ideas won't survive the research. Sometimes the story you wanted to write is not the story the evidence supports. That is not failure. That is the job.
Don't mistake confidence for being right, or long words for being clever. Ask questions. Check the evidence. Think about who disagrees with you and why. Then show your working.
I kept The Aston Goose going on an Instagram page because I believed students had something worth saying. I still do. I would rather publish a well-researched piece that disagrees with me than a lazy one that agrees with me. The Aston Goose exists to give you a platform, not to tell you what to think. All I ask in return is that you take your words, your evidence and your readers seriously.
Jaffer Ali
Founding Editor, The Aston Goose
theastongoose.com
