Birmingham
The Aston Goose
ASTON & BIRMINGHAM

Est. 2020

Our story
The independent student newspaper for Aston and Birmingham.
GOOSE WIRE
BIRMINGHAM3D-printed hearts help advance children’s cardiac careAston University · 12 Nov, 10:09
BIRMINGHAMClean Energy Jobs Fair held in BirminghamGOV.UK · 12 Nov, 15:21 · OGL v3.0
UK · Opinion

Burnham’s report card: bold at home, a bystander abroad

Four months in, Labour’s new prime minister has made ambitious promises at home. The test is what those promises deliver, and how much influence Britain can exert abroad.

Four months in, Labour’s new prime minister has made ambitious promises at home. The test is what those promises deliver, and how much influence Britain can exert abroad.

Andy Burnham became prime minister on 20 July 2026 after winning Labour’s leadership. Britain changed its head of government through a party leadership contest, rather than a general election.

The Aston Goose backs his direction of travel. That’s exactly why he should be judged on results, not speeches.

The scorecard

Area What he promised What happened Grade
Rough sleeping End it; his “first instruction” £340m additional funding announced on day one; a £442m, three-year Rough Sleeping Programme followed Strong start
Housing costs Make life affordable Housing benefit freeze kept in the budget; campaigners say it undercuts the pledge Contradiction
Israel and Palestine Do more than condemn Settlement import ban announced, with legislation still to come; restrictions on future arms licences extended Real, but limited
Iran war Push for de-escalation US bombers still fly from UK bases; no influence on ending the war Failing
Ukraine Lead the Coalition of the Willing Kyiv visit, missile production help; absent from the actual peace table Loyal, not decisive
Europe Closer ties UK–EU summit set for 20 November Too early to grade

Where he has delivered

On Israel’s occupation, Burnham did what Starmer would not. In September his government announced a ban on imports from illegal West Bank settlements, with legislation expected within six to nine months. It also said it would refuse export licence applications for items that materially contribute to the occupation. Parliament’s briefing records that no additional licences had been suspended or revoked immediately after the announcement. Israel retaliated by closing Britain’s consulate in east Jerusalem and banning 11 MPs. Burnham told Parliament Britain had to stand for fairness against injustice.

It matters, but measure it honestly: settlement exports are small, so the economic effect is limited. Campaigners and parliamentarians have called for broader sanctions. The government has said its new trade measures target settlement activity, while supporting trade with Israel within its internationally recognised borders.

Where Britain has no say

The Iran war is the clearest failure, and it lands in your weekly shop. Britain did not join the US and Israeli strikes. But Starmer allowed US forces to use British bases for what were called defensive operations, and Burnham has kept that permission. US heavy bombers have operated from RAF Fairford in Gloucestershire. A YouGov poll in the summer found most Britons opposed the arrangement. Iran has since declared the Royal Navy and RAF “terrorist organisations” under its law.

So Britain carries the risk of the war without any power over how it ends. Shipping through the Strait of Hormuz has been severely disrupted since the war began in February. The deals that might reopen it are being brokered by Pakistan and Qatar, not London. After the US midterms, Burnham said there was an “opportunity” to end the war. He has no lever to make it happen.

Ukraine is a similar story. Burnham visited Kyiv, where he co-chaired the Coalition of the Willing and backed Ukrainian missile production. Britain’s support now tops £25 billion. But the talks that could end the war resume in Abu Dhabi this week between the US, Russia and Ukraine. British officials attended only part of the last round. Russia’s demands, including Ukraine giving up four regions, have not moved.

The fair counter-argument

Britain is a middle power. No prime minister could stop a US president, or force Moscow to compromise. Supporters say Burnham’s real test is domestic, and there he has moved fast. Critics on the right make a different case: Conservative MP Bernard Jenkin warned the settlement ban could cost Britain counter-terror cooperation with Israel, and some commentators argue the tax burden, not foreign wars, is what’s really squeezing households.

The Aston Goose’s verdict

Right instincts, real early wins at home. Abroad, Britain is following, not leading. If Burnham wants to bring bills down, the hardest question he faces is whether British bases should keep supporting a war that is costing British households.

Sources: Wikipedia: 2026 local elections, PBS NewsHour, NBC News, Big Issue: rough sleeping, AP via KSAT: settlement trade ban, Breitbart/AP: arms embargo, Middle East Eye: Iran choices and YouGov poll, CNBC: RAF Fairford, Wikipedia: reactions to the Iran war, Courthouse News: Kyiv visit, The Citizen/Reuters: £25bn support, House of Commons Library: Ukraine talks, Axios: Abu Dhabi talks, News Today: Russia’s demands, Wikipedia: Burnham premiership.

Further sources: Prime Minister’s official biography, Commons Library: UK–Israel relations, Government: Rough Sleeping Programme.